Miami Dolphins vs Cleveland Browns Match Player Stats: Complete Box Score, Top Performers & Game Highlights
Both these teams came in at 1-5. Both were embarrassing their fanbases on a weekly basis. And somehow, one of them completely dominated the other by 25 points. In a rainstorm. At home. With a rookie quarterback. Figure that out.
Quick Facts
| Detail | Info |
| Date | October 19, 2025 |
| Venue | Huntington Bank Field, Cleveland |
| Final Score | Browns 31 – Dolphins 6 |
| Browns Record (after) | 2-5 |
| Dolphins Record (after) | 1-6 |
| Weather | Rain, 65°F, 17 mph S wind |
| Browns Top Scorer | Quinshon Judkins – 3 TDs |
| Dolphins Top Scorer | Nobody. Two field goals. |
| Browns QB | Dillon Gabriel (13/18, 116 yds, 0 INT) |
| Dolphins QB | Tua Tagovailoa (12/23, 100 yds, 3 INT) — benched |
| Game MVP | Quinshon Judkins, unofficially and officially |
A Game That Happened Between Two Teams That Had No Business Playing Like This
Let’s be real. When you circle October 19, 2025 on the NFL calendar, you’re not circling it because Cleveland vs. Miami matters. You’re circling it for literally anything else. Two 1-5 squads, mid-October, random Sunday. Sounds like the game you watch while doing laundry.
Except it wasn’t that. At all.
The Browns turned this into a clinic. Cleveland picked up its second win of the season, beating Miami 31-6 on a wet Sunday at Huntington Bank Field. And they did it not through some miraculous last-second drive. They just… ground Miami into the mud. Literally. It was raining.
What makes this story interesting isn’t just the final score. It’s WHO put it together. We’re talking about a 22-year-old rookie running back from Pike Road, Alabama. A rookie quarterback who had not thrown a single interception in his first 100-plus professional pass attempts. And a defense that made Tua Tagovailoa look like he’d never watched a film in his life.
See also “Average Height in the WNBA: How Tall Are WNBA Players?“
Quinshon Judkins: The Kid Who Refused to Be Stopped
The Browns relied on the running game, primarily utilizing Judkins, who finished with 84 rushing yards and three touchdowns on 25 carries.
That looks fine on paper. Good, even. But the stats don’t tell you what actually happened on that field.
The defining moment came with 11:19 left in the second quarter. Judkins blasted through a hole, took off for 46 yards, and multiple Dolphins defenders tried to grab him — but amid the rain, they couldn’t get a firm grasp of his jersey. Once past the first level, only safety Minkah Fitzpatrick stood between him and the end zone. Fitzpatrick dove to wrap up Judkins’ legs, but the Browns back slipped out and sped away to score.
The run was the longest of Judkins’ career. He had 75 rushing yards already at halftime on 18 attempts. And then he came back out for the second half and scored twice more out of the wildcat. Three touchdowns. His fifth career sack. A career-long 46-yarder. All in the rain.
Judkins was drafted 36th overall by Cleveland in the 2025 draft out of Ohio State. Born October 29, 2003 — this kid literally just turned 22 years old. His rookie season was highlighted by several standout performances that put him on the map as one of the promising young talents in the league. You want specifics? He finished 2025 with 827 rushing yards, a 3.6 average, and 7 touchdowns across 14 games.
That’s not spectacular yards-per-carry, honestly. The offensive line wasn’t always doing him favors. But seven touchdowns as a rookie? That’s a foundation. And against Miami in Week 7 specifically, he was the best player on that soggy field, by a country mile.
Dillon Gabriel: Calm, Cool, Doing His Rookie Thing
Let’s talk about the Browns quarterback situation for a second, because it’s genuinely fascinating. Third-round pick Dillon Gabriel made his starts this season and had not thrown an interception in his first 89 career passing attempts at the point this game was played.
That’s remarkable. An NFL rookie. Zero picks. Zero. Gabriel had completed 13 of 18 passes for 116 yards and zero interceptions in this game. No touchdowns through the air, sure. But he wasn’t asked to win it. He was asked not to lose it, and he delivered exactly that.
For a team that went most of 2024 watching Deshaun Watson self-destruct, Gabriel was a breath of fresh air just by not throwing the ball to the other team. While Gabriel remained a work in progress, he had not thrown an interception in his three starts at that point.
The contrast with the quarterback at the other end of the field is almost comically stark. One guy completes 72% of his passes, doesn’t turn it over once, and efficiently manages a rain game. The other guy has a 24.1 passer rating. We’ll get to that.
Tua Tagovailoa: This Was Already a Problem, And It Only Got Worse
Here’s the thing about Tua. The game against Cleveland wasn’t a one-off, weather-related bad day. It was Week 7 of a full-on tailspin.
In this game, Tagovailoa completed 12-of-23 passes for 100 yards, no touchdowns, and three interceptions — his second straight game with three interceptions. This performance was becoming the norm, not the outlier, for Tagovailoa that season.
He also fumbled three times on the day, though none were lost. The man had 23 total snaps in the pocket and produced a passer rating of 24.1. For comparison, a passer rating of 39.6 is what you’d get for throwing the ball out of bounds every single play. Tua didn’t even reach that theoretical floor of mediocrity.
The Cleveland defense forced Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa to throw three interceptions. DE Myles Garrett, S Grant Delpit, and LB Jerome Baker all recorded sacks as the Browns held the Dolphins to their lowest-scoring game of the season.
After another interception late in the game, Miami coach Mike McDaniel pulled him. Tagovailoa was benched for rookie seventh-round pick Quinn Ewers after throwing interceptions on consecutive drives late in the game.
Ewers came in and went 5-of-8 for 53 yards. No TDs, no picks, a rating of 81.8. By comparison? He looked like Joe Montana.
Look. I’m not here to pile on Tua. He had a genuinely good 2023 season — he completed 388-of-560 passes for a league-best 4,624 yards, 29 touchdowns, and 14 interceptions for a 101.1 passer rating that year. That version of Tua was real.
But by 2025? An NFL defensive coach who had prepared against him put it bluntly to ESPN — he saw a quarterback who couldn’t function after his initial read, then found himself on the interception train almost every week.
That is as brutal as it sounds. Tagovailoa ranked 30th in QBR at 36.7 that season, down sharply from 10th in 2023 and 15th in 2024.
That’s not a slump. That’s a cliff.
The Secondary That Made Cleveland Look Elite for One Afternoon
You want to talk about an underrated group? The Cleveland defensive backfield in this game was something.
Three interceptions total. Three. All off Tua, all in key moments, all killing whatever slim hope Miami had of crawling back.
CB Tyson Campbell recorded his first interception as a Brown, a 34-yard pick-six. Safeties Rayshawn Jenkins and Ronnie Hickman also had interceptions.
Campbell’s was the most dramatic. Tua tried to throw a quick screen to De’Von Achane, but the pass was too high. Jenkins hit Achane to knock him off-balance mid-attempt, and Campbell swooped in from behind, snagged the deflection, toed the sideline and turned on the jets for a 34-yard touchdown. The pick-six was Campbell’s first of his career and extended the Browns’ lead to 24-6.
That was the game. Done. Put a bow on it.
Cleveland’s defense held the Dolphins to a 1-for-13 conversion rate on third downs — their lowest third-down percentage allowed since holding the Bengals to just over 7% back in November of 2013.
That is historic-level third down defense. Against a team that had Miami’s weapons. Achane couldn’t generate anything meaningful. Jaylen Waddle caught one pass for 15 yards on four targets. The only Dolphin with any real production through the air was backup receiver Dee Eskridge, who somehow went for 2 catches and 45 yards — the most of anyone on Miami that day.
That’s not supposed to be your story.
Myles Garrett, Chasing Ghosts in a Rain Game
DE Myles Garrett recorded two tackles, two tackles for a loss, and a sack in this game. Those are his quiet-game numbers. And even that — in the rain, against a struggling offense — was productive.
By this point in the 2025 season, Garrett was quietly on pace for something historic. He was tied for fourth in the NFL with 8 tackles for loss and had added 4.0 sacks entering this matchup.
The numbers that matter more for context: at that stage, Garrett had accumulated 107.5 career sacks before turning 30 years old, ranking second all-time among players under 30, with Reggie White’s record of 108 sitting just above him.
In a 31-6 blowout against a team throwing three interceptions, you don’t necessarily need Garrett to go nuclear. He was a steady, constant presence. Added a sack. Messed up the pocket. His fifth sack of the season, in fact.
Garrett is the kind of player where even a “quiet” game still matters. Cleveland’s defense held Miami to 219 total yards. When your best pass rusher is just there, being himself, quarterbacks start making bad decisions faster.
Three interceptions worth of bad decisions, specifically.
De’Von Achane Deserved Better From This Game
One thing that bothers me about how this game is remembered. De’Von Achane carried the ball 13 times for 82 yards at a 6.3 average, with a long of 46 yards.
That’s solid work. Really solid, actually. 6.3 yards per carry on a day when the weather was garbage and the team’s quarterback couldn’t put together a single scoring drive. Achane was the one guy keeping Miami from getting completely blanked on offense for the first three quarters.
But here’s the thing — when your QB is turning it over three times, it doesn’t matter if your running back is averaging over six yards a pop. You’re not scoring. You’re running into walls. In the passing game, Achane also contributed three receptions for 16 yards.
This kid can play. The 2025 Dolphins just made it impossible for it to matter.
Rookie Watch: Carson Schwesinger Was Already Putting Up Numbers
Before we leave the Browns’ defense, credit where it’s due. Second-round pick LB Carson Schwesinger was leading all NFL rookies in tackles at that point in the season. Against Miami, he had 7 tackles and a tackle for loss.
He’s not flashy. He’s not making the highlight reel. But a linebacker who is everywhere on the field, in his first year, leading all first-year players in tackles league-wide? That’s real production. That’s a guy who does the unsexy work that actually wins games.
The 2025 Browns draft class as a whole was making an immediate impact. Judkins producing on the ground. Gabriel not throwing picks. First-round DT Mason Graham had already recorded 14 tackles and helped anchor a defense that ranked third in total defense and third in run defense in the NFL.
For a team that ended the week at 2-5, the foundation was clearly better than the record suggested.
The 1-13 Third Down Stat Is Actually Insane
I want to come back to this because it deserves more attention.
The Miami Dolphins converted one out of thirteen third-down opportunities in this game. ONE. Thirteen attempts. The Browns’ third-down defense held the Dolphins to 1-of-13 conversions.
Think about what that means. It means that every single time Miami needed to extend a drive, they couldn’t. Almost without exception. For sixty minutes of football, in front of their own fans, against a Cleveland team that also had a losing record, the Dolphins offense was completely dead on arrival.
That’s not weather. That’s not bad luck. That’s a defensive identity showing up.
Now contrast that with the Dolphins’ own defense in this game. They gave up 206 total yards to Cleveland. They had four sacks on the day. They gave the Browns 4-for-11 on third downs. That’s actually not terrible. Cleveland’s offense wasn’t lighting the world on fire either.
But Cleveland’s offense scored 31 points anyway. Because of turnovers. Because of Judkins. Because of the pick-six.
Sometimes football is just about which team stops being stupid first.
What This Game Actually Meant in the Bigger Picture
Miami fell to 1-6. The Dolphins offense ranked bottom-10 in total yards, passing yards, rushing yards, and points per game through that stretch. This was a team built for a Super Bowl run a couple years prior, now getting humiliated by a 1-5 Cleveland squad.
Tua went on to finish that season with 15 interceptions, leading the entire NFL in picks. Coach Mike McDaniel eventually pulled the plug on Tagovailoa after 14 games in 2025 — the first time since Tua’s rookie year that he finished with a passer rating under 90. He was later released by Miami entirely.
For Cleveland, this was supposed to be a spark. And it kind of was, for a bit. The Browns won a few more before finishing with a disappointing overall season. Judkins eventually suffered a knee injury late in the year that cut his rookie campaign short. Gabriel had growing pains of his own as the season wore on.
But this Sunday, in the rain, in Cleveland? The Browns were the best team on that field. No debate.
Final Thoughts
Here’s my take. Quinshon Judkins is the reason this game is remembered. Not the defense, not Gabriel, not Myles Garrett’s sack. It’s the 22-year-old rookie who carried the ball 25 times, slipped out of Minkah Fitzpatrick’s arms in the rain, hit the longest run of his life, and then came back and scored two more times in the wildcat.
Three touchdowns. Career-long run. Win. In the rain. At home. As a rookie.
Meanwhile Tua Tagovailoa — a guy who was considered a top-10 quarterback two years earlier — threw three picks, fumbled three times, and got yanked for a seventh-round pick named Quinn Ewers. That is a fall from grace that should genuinely make you uncomfortable.
This wasn’t a fluke win for Cleveland. The defense was real. Gabriel was smart and clean. Judkins was explosive. All three interceptions thrown by Tua came when Cleveland was playing zone coverage — the most a defense had picked off in zone coverage since Buffalo two years prior.
That’s a prepared team. That’s a coaching staff that did their homework. That was Cleveland’s best day in two full seasons, by their own admission.
Enjoy it, Browns fans. Because wins like this, clean wins, 25-point wins where everything clicks — they don’t come every week when you’re 1-5. This one was earned.
FAQs
1. Who won the Browns vs Dolphins game in Week 7, 2025?
The Cleveland Browns won, beating Miami 31-6 on October 19, 2025, at Huntington Bank Field.
2. How many touchdowns did Quinshon Judkins score?
Judkins scored three touchdowns on 25 carries for 84 yards, including a 46-yard run that was the longest of his career at that point.
3. What happened to Tua Tagovailoa in this game?
Tagovailoa completed 12-of-23 passes for 100 yards with no touchdowns and three interceptions. He was benched late in the game for rookie Quinn Ewers after throwing interceptions on back-to-back drives.
4. Who had the pick-six for Cleveland?
Cornerback Tyson Campbell returned a tipped pass 34 yards for a touchdown — the first pick-six of his career.
5. Was Dillon Gabriel good in this game?
Yes. He went 13-of-18 for 116 yards and zero interceptions, managing the game efficiently in tough weather conditions
6. What was Tua’s season stat line in 2025?
Tagovailoa started 14 games and threw for 2,660 yards, 20 touchdowns, and 15 interceptions for a passer rating of 88.5.
7. Was De’Von Achane any good in this game?
Actually, yes. Achane had 13 carries for 82 yards at a 6.3 average, but Miami’s turnover problems made his production irrelevant.
8. What was Myles Garrett doing in this game?
Garrett recorded two tackles, two tackles for a loss, and a sack — his fifth of the season at that point.
9. How did Cleveland’s defense look overall?
The Browns held Miami to 219 total yards, four turnovers, and just 1-of-13 on third downs. That’s near-perfect defensive efficiency.
10. Did Jaylen Waddle participate in this game?
Barely. Waddle was targeted four times and caught just one pass for 15 yards.
11. What was the weather like?
Rain fell throughout the game, with 17 mph southerly winds — which directly contributed to Judkins’ big touchdown run when defenders couldn’t get a grip on his wet jersey.
12. Did the Browns win more after this?
They got some more wins as the season progressed, but Judkins suffered a season-ending knee injury late in the year. Dillon Gabriel also had a concussion that sidelined him during a stretch run. The 2025 Browns were a team with a real foundation, but couldn’t stay healthy long enough to build on it.
Discover stories that stand at the top with The Pinnacle Magazine.
